Gale: Built on top of an old Indian burial ground. Just kidding, but it does have the original 1941 art deco structure and terrazzo.
The James: Back in the day, the James was one of the first hotels to ever open on the beach.
The Edge: The James. Being first has to count for something.
Gale: Italian linen sheets, a 55-inch LED TV and a bedside button that summons an emergency turndown service.
The James: A 42-inch plasma TV, a minibar with full-size bottles and organic pillows.
The Edge: The James. And the free-range bedding takes it.
The Pool Situation
Gale: A black-marble infinity pool that looks out on both the ocean and the city. Keep your head on a swivel.
The James: Two swimming pools... and a waterfall-equipped jacuzzi plunge pool.
The Edge: Tie. There are no losers here, really.
The X Factor
Gale: Access to all of the beachside offerings at the neighboring Shelborne—including chaises and chili dogs from Lucy’s Cantina Royale.
The James: Complimentary Kindles/iPads to use while you sun.
The Edge: Gale. Chili dogs taste better than Kindles.