Alley Cat Amateur Theatre: Discreet Cocktailing Beneath The Beekman

Serge Becker (of The Box, Miss Lily's, La Esquina) Is Behind It

By Ilana Dadras ·
Photo: Oleg March

TGI (an absolutely goddamn beautiful) F. 

TG, also, that we've got a shiny new cocktail spot for you to hit this weekend. It's a discreet lounge tucked into The Beekman's cellar, and it's now open in FiDi.

You'll find it on a small, winding street aptly dubbed Theatre Alley—follow the blue neon cat and enter through an otherwise nondescript door. What you'll find down there is a once-hidden century-old mechanical room full of wild patterns and leather couches: a space with old world charm that feels somewhat like you're backstage at a show. It's a vibe that's somehow both welcoming and exclusive...a feat considering they're on a mission to make it decidedly low key: no velvet ropes, no pretentious doormen, no line outside (though don't quote us on that last claim).

So stop by after work or make it a pit stop on a night out: the late-night impresario behind The Box, La Esquina, and Miss Lily's is behind it, so you can expect quality DJs, the occasional intimate concert and a more-than-decent crowd. Come with someone you're into and have a couple of Green Toki Highballs (whiskey, sencha tea, lemongrass honey) or Spaghetti Easterns (gin, coconut, shishito). Pair them with some soy-braised short ribs or fried quail with pear chutney or anything else on the izakaya-inspired menu. Call it a night.

Some photos, now, and we will send you on your weekend-ing way.

Alley Cat Amateur Theatre, 10 Theatre Alley (at Beekman St), 212-461-4300, see the menu and the slideshow

Ilana Dadras

Ilana Dadras passes her days writing about good food, talking about good food and consuming good food. Occasionally doing other things, too.

Elsewhere on the Daddy

More Nightlife in New York