Sign Up

UrbanDaddy is a free exclusive email magazine devoted to keeping you in the know.

Join Now

Norman Conquest

The Grey Lady Guys’ New Spot on the LES

Welcome to October.

The month of crispy leaves, borderline-indecent costume parties, breezy island paradises and the ongoing debate about what constitutes “fun-size.”

Oh, you noticed we threw “breezy island paradises” in there. We can explain...

Meet Norman’s Cay, a whitewashed, two-story tribute to the Caribbean from the Grey Lady guys, opening Friday on the LES.

Think about Grey Lady. Now halve it, strap a ’66 Cessna to the ceiling, toss in a solid helping of Caribbean sea life and move the after-hours partying to an upstairs bar. Boom, this place.

You know those friendly dinners you have with a few friends that morph into rum-fueled 3am dance parties—the Cay was made for those. First: the eating. Lionfish is the specialty here. It’s an invasive(ly delicious) species down there, so they’re exacting vengeance by spearing it themselves, then frying it whole or ceviche-ifying it. You’ll flank it with conch salad and, possibly, a spiny-tail-lobster roll.

Once that’s settled, move past the wall-mounted sailfish and upstairs. There you’re going to find a long banquette, a DJ blasting occasional reggae and yourself feeling funny after the dark-and-light-rum-egg-white-and-nutmeg killer known as the Rum Dum.

That’s what we call a truth-in-advertising drink.


Norman’s Cay
74 Orchard St
(between Grand and Broome)
New York, NY 10002
official website


More Food

@UrbanDaddy | Take your pleasure seriously.